Sam thinks he has the answer: find the girl of his dreams and his problems are solved. His roommate Cole, still spinning from a break-up, doesn't believe in true love. Their best friend Zach does - if it involves Hannah - but does she feel the same way? Over a beautiful spring weekend in New York City, these three young men find themselves face to face with their true loves. The beautiful and exotic Eva literally "steps" into Sam's life, Cole and Devon reconsider their break-up and Zach summons the courage to confess his true feelings to Hannah. Will these bumbling heroes find true love before Sunday night? Spin the bottle to find out.

In the 1980s two short story writers, desperate for an idea, conjure inspiration by meddling with their neighbor's private affairs.