After the latest two victims of The Hole Puncher, a serial killer targeting gay college students are found dead on their Grindr hookup, 21-year-old Cody is suspected of their murder. To clear his name, he must team with the police to seduce and catch the killer once and for all.

At Thanksgiving dinner, Becca expects to be named her niece’s godmother, only to discover that her sister’s two gay best friends have been named the godfathers.