During a classic 50s barbeque, newlywed Barbra “accidentally” murders her husband. Upon learning of the tragedy, her best friends gather around her and help hide the evidence from the men at the party, as well as distracting Nancy, the detective’s wife. As Barbra tells Nancy stories to distract her, we learn the truth of their marriage, and of her husband’s temperament. As the friends work together to save Barbra, we see the true combined strength of women. But will they get away with their crime? And what on earth will they do with the body?

A college costume party is interrupted as a murderous killer acts out the contents of a screenplay he is writing to ensure its believability. Loser and Superhero find themselves in the killer’s clutches as he attempts to iron out a grand finale for his film. He leads them through his kills, explaining his vision, and as the credits are bound to begin rolling soon Loser and Superhero are left with one thought: will this film have a final girl? And which one of them is it going to be?