Dateless yet again on Valentine's Day, nerdy high school student Sean takes it upon himself to woo the new girl in town Jennifer by means of a seemingly simple gesture: bringing her flowers.

Just when their separation is coming to an end, and Kyle and Sophia have recommitted to each other, Sophia is accused of assaulting her husband's "friend," Claire, a woman he slept with once. In reality, however, Claire is engineering a series of attacks against herself to frame Sophia and keep Kyle for herself. When the ruse falls apart, Claire makes a direct attack on her rival.