When a socially awkward teen, Daniel, discovers the identity of the infamous “Jack-O’-Lantern Killer,” he sees a dark path to fulfilling his deepest desires. Mentored by the killer himself, Daniel aims to carry on the gruesome legacy, but his own ineptitude threatens to derail all of his hopes and dreams.

While on a venture to satisfy his hunger, Chris (a fuzzy purple puppet) gets wrapped up with two criminals with more violent means of accomplishing the same goal.