It's 1987, and Kristin is the new girl in town. With the insistence of her cousin, Natalie, Kristin is swayed to attend the birthday party of Jennifer- the most popular girl in school. But tonight, high school reputations are the least of their worries. With recent news of a homicidal maniac escaping a nearby hospital, party guests begin to disappear one by one.

Set in the world of No More Lonely People, childhood friends reunite to celebrate Angelo, the last of their group to turn twenty three. As the night progresses old feelings come up and they start to question whether the system is perfect.