If Our Girls Won't Do It tells convincing stories of straight guys turning gay for their best buddies even as they are in denial, shown via gradually escalating exploratory sex acts that start with "totally not gay" side-by-side masturbation that eventually turns into more as they convince themselves and each other using flimsy excuses to justify their curiosity...

Frat twink Finn August couldn't care less about sports, but when he sees hottie Drake Von watching the soccer game with his frat bro, he's willing to pretend. Finn offers Drake a snack that's really a stroker in a chip can and slides it down the horny top's big cock, then replaces it with his mouth. Finn straddles Drake and rides his cock, then the top licks Finn's hole and fucks him on all fours. The bottom cums as Drake penetrates him in spoon position, then the top drills him on his back before he shoots his load on Finn's face and feeds it to him on a chip in Sportsmen 2.