Charlie Baker is a college student who struggles to make ends meet. When he receives a letter, which was supposed to go to someone named Lennox with a secret code, it leads him and his reluctant roommate, Elliot, to the door of a secret fraternity on campus. To have one last bit of fun before he's kicked out, Charlie assumes Lennox's identity and attempts to join the brothers of this odd society.

Cleo, a young woman who wears her heart on her sleeve, has just been dumped by her high school sweetheart. Determined to lift her spirits, her best friend Suki sets her up on a series of blind dates—each one more disastrous than the last.