A skeptical journalist is assigned to chronicle the 50th anniversary of Kris Kringle, a Santa Claus in the town of Mistletoe. As her involvement in the town grows, she begins to open up to the enchantment of Christmas and some other wonders of the season.

A gorgeous lakeside cabin plays host to a pair of restless wraths. One of them seems trapped above the rickety old staircase, the other in the darkest corner of a creepy basement. A decorative suit of arms affectionately dubbed "The Don: stands between them, protecting those who wish to be protected. The tales of haunted rooms seem harmless, at first, and in fact add to the appeal of the old cabin. But the spirits are growing restless.

Actor Michael Madsen turns the tables on notorious paparazzo, Billy Dant, by hiring a trio of documentary filmmakers to chronicle Dant's life, loves, and troubles.