James, Kat, Sherrie, and Brian reunite for a movie night as they welcome a new guest, Julie, Brian's girlfriend. As the night progresses and the movie is being dissected by the group, a heated discussion about male gaze surfaces, but in the midst of the discussion and movie, they discover an unlikely connection to real life, one that attaches Julie and her real life job.

A gay high school student throws a swinging prom party in the hopes of finally wooing the football captain - but when popular kids start turning up dead, the partygoers discover a slasher killer amongst the student body!

A young man and a young woman send video messages back and forth from afar, brainstorming a movie to make together in the future when they see each other again.