On December 24th, five seemingly random men are invited to a dive bar by a mysterious e-mail. They decide to pass the time by resurrecting the old tradition of telling scary stories on Christmas Eve.

Max and his girlfriend Hannah travel to the rural South to spend Christmas with Max's eclectic family. When Hannah gets bitten by a deer, strange things begin to occur.

When people in their hometown begin dying on the anniversary of an accused witch's execution, a depressed journalist and his teenage sister set out to uncover the truth behind a local legend.