After being left home alone during Christmas with an escaped mental patient on the loose, Cindy decides to spend the holiday with her friends. What was thought to be a peaceful holiday, quickly turns into a nightmare, proving there is no such thing as a silent night.

In 1989, in the small town of Stillwater, two high schoolers and three young adults begin to experience strange occurrences and disappearances.

After stumbling upon a mysterious item that has the ability to grant you one wish, Chris attempts to save his friendship when he finds out his friend is moving to New York.