In present-day New York, Maya marries the first man she has ever dated. The entire film is their heartfelt conversation about how Maya had no time to learn who she really is. It is a conversation about diversity and unpredictability of human sexuality and about the place of queer and LGBT identities within the traditional Jewish worldview.

The lives of four strangers intertwine when a couple's anniversary night spirals into a whirlwind of bizarre run-ins, chance encounters, and a frantic search for baby formula.