George Lutz, his wife Kathy, and their three children have just moved into a beautiful, and improbably cheap, Dutch colonial mansion nestled in the sleepy coastal town of Amityville, Long Island. However, their dream home is concealing a horrific past and soon each member of the Lutz family is plagued with increasingly strange and violent visions and impulses.

Casey, a vice president of her father's company, has nobody in her life. But one night, she meets three eligible bachelors: a preppy old friend, a star quarterback, and a waiter / musician. With the help of her (horny) friend, she must decide the outcome of the dating game.