Roni and Bri have fallen in a forbidden love, where lies and secrets lead to the end of their relationship. Bri tries desperately to move on and forget her past love with Roni. But, she's in for an unexpected surprise when secrets are revealed and her life is now a twisted love triangle with her past.

A love story based around two characters - Angela and Tennille. Growing up through out the years Angela, a heterosexual female, never realizes that Tennille, a dominant female, is deeply in love with her. After several years of Angela being in the dark about Tennille's true feelings, she soon discovers the love that Tennille has for her and realizes those feelings are mutual.

In the completion of The Lies We Tell Part 4 Movie Series, Roni and Bri attempt to relocate for a new start but are derailed back to Chicago. Deceit and new obstacles find them fighting to keep their family together.

Obstacles derail Roni and Bri's attempt at a fresh start, but what is done in the dark always come to light.