In a small Catholic boarding school an unspeakable act has been committed. When High School student, Luther Scott, confesses to Father Michael Kelly, Kelly is bound silent to the particulars of a grisly murder. Now, framed guilty by the desperate teen, Kelly must decide to keep his silence or throw away everything the priesthood holds sacred.

A documentary exploring the events leading up to the 1994 murder of 14-year-old Andrea Hines by her 13-year-old friend, Adan, and its lasting impact on the community.