After a cult leader “raptures” alone with his followers’ donation money, two cult members reenter the secular world to embark on a manhunt for their swindler from rural Ohio to New York City.

When an exciting stranger named Vi comes to twins Jesse and Kurt’s small town looking for rare videotapes, their lives unravel into uncertainty. As Vi’s life tangles with their own, the twins are forced to confront whether their post-college lives are comfortable, complaisant, or worse.