Christina and Keith are childhood friends who see each other at a mutual friend's birthday party. They recall old memories and find themselves seeing each other in a new way.

Charlie Young and Daisy Palmer are two of four college actors competing in a theater production in hopes of being awarded a scholarship to NYU. Their director assigns Charlie and Daisy the roles of husband and wife and asks them to replicate their stage relationships outside of the theater before rehearsals.

When Olivia's (Viva Valdez) boyfriend, Francis (Christian Sullivan) starts acting suspicious, she begins to uncover clues of another woman in his life. What she discovers, however, is not proof of another person but proof two of her multiple personalities.