CEO of the Morton Pumpkin Company decides to commemorate the 200th anniversary of the cutest town ever founded with a bake-off. The town sweetheart is expected to win. When her niece is left to stay, winning seems out of reach.

Pranks are a tradition in the neighbourhood, so when teenager Teagan is kidnapped, her parent's just think it's a prank. Fortunately, her sisters and other neighbourhood kids know better and spring into action, to rescue her using their best pranks.

The residents of Hope, NY come to the aid of displaced foster children after St. Jerome's Home for Children has a fire right before Christmas, and many families find the foster children complete their homes.

A young boy overcomes the communication obstacle he has with the object of his affection: A deaf girl.

When Mrs. Claus and Santa sign the divorce decree, they return to their 40 year old selves and re-enter the dating pool.

Joy and Hope McGregor run Two Sisters Ranch upstate New York with their dad and longtime friend. When a handsome stranger comes to town to find inspiration to get over writer's block, he learns how special Christmas on the ranch really is.