Paul Matthews only wanted to record his new song. Instead he records a murder. Now, he's got two cops who won't leave him alone. The victim's best friend following him everywhere and his bandmates wondering just where the hell he is at. But for the killer, one murder is not enough. Paul and his tape will have to be erased.

Ray and his friends have come up with a great prank. They are going to kidnap a fellow high school student and hide him in an underwater cave. All is fun until the student accidentally drowns. Ray becomes obsessed with keeping the death a secret but his friends become more worried by the minute and think that they should report the death to the police. Ray will do anything he can to prevent this from happening. The bonds of friendship begin to fray and the lines of trust become blurrier by the minute building to a tragic climax.