Jay and Talya meet for a blind date, both nervously relying on prepared lists to make a good impression. After a rocky start, they bond over their mutual romantic failures and emotional baggage, deciding to ditch the formalities and take a walk together. As they share stories about past relationships, heartbreak, and personal growth, they begin to connect on a deeper level.

It is six months after The Debate. Kevin Alcazar has taken office as President, and he has just gotten rid of Nick's favorite chicken fingers. In response, Nick holds a funeral for them where things get wild and Nick must navigate the cruel world without his chicken fingers.