Connor Storrie

John Wayne Gacy

Madison McGovern

Gacy's Mom / Wife 2 (Carole Hoth)

David Kohn

Gacy's Dad

Maddie Wechsler

Wife 1 (Marlynn Myers)

Shane Cronin

Pastor / Victim 1 (Mark)

Josh Cronin

Victim 2

Preston Glenn

Victim 3

Gisele Hakim

Victim's Mother

Justin Appell

Cop 1

Nicole Youhanaie

Cop 2